Skip to content

Review guide

Review one AI-reported finding against the submitted Define-XML, the reproduced yamaa specification and the ADaM data. No installation is needed; one evidence-backed recommendation is a complete contribution. Results are drafts pending human review.

1. Choose a finding

Open the Pilot 5 consistency findings and select Start review on a finding. Start with Critical finding: Yes or Needs review. Use By dataset to choose another dataset.

2. Check the evidence

Read The finding. Compare the cited Define-XML item with the reproduced yamaa specification, then check Subject examples for the reported difference. Use View source to inspect a citation.

Decide whether the evidence supports the finding and its criticality. A 100% reproduced ADaM dataset agreement does not resolve a disagreement between the data and Define-XML.

3. Submit your assessment

Under Human Review, choose Agree, Disagree or Need clarification, then Critical, Not critical or Unsure, and explain your reasoning. Drafts save automatically in this browser.

Select Submit review on GitHub after both decisions. Sign in if asked, check the prefilled assessment, then select Start discussion to publish it. Opening the GitHub form does not submit your review.

Open the pilot study report to review another pilot study.